Why Knack & Tumbler Search
We Unlock the Leaders Others Can't Reach.
Generalist retained firms spend the first 60 days learning what S/4HANA or BTP actually means. We spent 25+ years building the technical teams underneath these transformations. That difference is the entire value proposition.
The Problem With Generalist Retained Firms
A generalist firm takes your retainer, posts the role on LinkedIn, and calls the same 40 people every other firm calls. They interview candidates on your behalf without the technical depth to distinguish a real transformation leader from someone who sat in the steering committee and took credit. By the time they figure out the difference, you've lost 90 days and a third of your retainer.
Deep Ecosystem Forensics
We know the org chart underneath the org chart.
Our network doesn't stop at the VP level. It includes the architects, program managers, functional leads, and SI partners who worked under these transformation executives. Before we present a candidate, we've already spoken to people who were in the room when the hard decisions were made. We know who drove the cutover and who disappeared when the go-live went sideways.
This is not a reference check you can replicate with a LinkedIn search. It requires 25 years of relationships built inside the ecosystem — relationships that only exist because we've been placing the technical talent underneath these leaders for decades.
De-Risking Nine-Figure Investments
A mis-hire at the VP level stalls a transformation by 12–18 months.
When a company commits $150M to an S/4HANA transformation, the VP of Enterprise Applications is the single highest-leverage hire in the program. The wrong person doesn't just slow the project — they create SI overruns, board-level credibility problems, and organizational damage that outlasts the transformation itself. The cost of a mis-hire at this level is not the recruiter's fee. It's the $20–40M in program overruns and the 18 months of lost competitive position.
Our retained process is designed around one question: has this person actually done this before, at this scale, in this kind of organization? We don't present candidates who can't answer that question with specifics.
The Bridge / Container Model
Retained accountability at Director and VP levels — without the Big 4 price tag.
Traditional retained search is priced for C-Suite engagements. For Director and VP roles in the $180k–$250k base range, the standard one-third/one-third/one-third model can feel misaligned with the role's scope. Our Engaged Container model offers a middle path: one-third upfront to fund dedicated market mapping and exclusivity, with the remaining two-thirds paid upon placement. You get the accountability and exclusivity of retained search with a payment structure that reflects the role.
This model is available for Director and VP roles where the client wants dedicated search capacity but the role scope doesn't justify a full executive retained engagement. We'll tell you honestly which model fits your situation.
The Right Firm for the Right Search
We are not the right firm for every search. If you need a generalist executive search for a non-technical role, there are excellent firms that do that well. If you need a VP of Enterprise Applications who has actually taken an S/4HANA program live at a Fortune 500 — or a CIO who can credibly lead a multi-cloud transformation while managing a $200M SI relationship — we are the right call.
“Recruiting is not an advertising or email business. It's a people business.”
— Knack & Tumbler Search
Tell Us About the Role
We'll tell you whether we're the right firm and what the market looks like — no commitment required.
Start a Confidential Conversation